Evaluation of the Schemes

more traditional building block
completes the north end of the North Quad
primary volume terminates the north/south axis of Parrish Hall and the North Quad
internal loop of circulation at the ground level and a continuous path at the second level
concentrates more program close to Martin Hall and the Science Commons
building extends into the North Quad further than the existing DuPont Lecture Hall
building will seem larger since all of the new construction is two stories above ground and central
closes off the view of the Harry Wood Garden from the Quad
creates a larger interior courtyard which is also accessible from the east
building entrance locations create new diagonal relationships to other buildings on campus - Beardsley Hall, Hicks Engineering Building and Trotter Quad

creates a public zone at the Quad level with the Science Commons and most of the classrooms
two lecture halls in the center flanking the entrance to the Harry Wood Garden
lecture halls need to be designed to mitigate the opaque character of their facades

two lecture halls at opposite ends of the site
classrooms and teaching laboratories in the central building
draws activity equally to both ends of the complex
places the 200 seat lecture hall away from the Science Commons and Biology
Organic Chemistry Laboratory positioned opposite the classrooms in the first level of the central building

between Cornell Library and the 80 person lecture hall
seating along the Quad edge and circulation along the north edge and sunken garden
channels all traffic along the interactive space on only one level
allows for a higher ceiling because it is only one story
open stair near Cornell Library gives access to the classrooms and Physics/Astronomy department below and to the Main floor of the Biology department and the second story overlook into the Science Commons

placed between the main entry point for Cornell Library and the Quad entrance for all departments except for the Biology department in Martin Hall
physically accessible and visually open to two levels on both sides
seating area is located on the north side, facing the Crum Woods and the west wing of DuPont and the circulation is along the Quad edge
open stair in the double height portion of the Science Commons connects Cornell Library with the second floor of the central building where Chemistry is located.

Physics/Astronomy area surrounds the lower courtyard
Math/Statistics at the first floor of the north building of DuPont with Computer Science above
Chemistry in an L shaped building on the east edge of the site
new Introduction to Biology Laboratory on the second floor of the new building in front of Cornell Library
strong adjacency between Chemistry and Biology
Biologists will have to go outside to get to the 200 seat lecture hall, or use the basement connection to transport experiments and displays.

Chemistry in the central building
new Introduction to Biology Laboratory on the second floor of the new building in front of Cornell Library
Math/Statistics located on the first floor of the west DuPont Building with Computer Science below
Physics/Astronomy placed in the north DuPont Building that connects to the east end of the new Chemistry wing
creates a strong connection between all of the building components on two levels
situates Chemistry and Biology as close as possible

both schemes work well
offer different possibilities
desire to have optimal circulation and traffic patterns is at odds with the idea of a building that is low scale and philosophically open to the rest of the campus

return to Home Page

Send message to the chair of the Science Project User's Group, Rachel Merz (rmerz1@swarthmore.edu)

last updated 11/23/99